De-icing Alternatives to Salt

With the recent snow and frigid temperatures, many of us have worked hard to clear our porches, driveways and sidewalks of snow and ice. Commonly we simply spread rock salt over these areas – it is simple and it works. Salt, though, can damage some metals, concrete, and asphalt, and can be harmful to plants, lakes and ponds, and drinking water. Less threatening alternatives to salt are readily available.

A low-corrosion alternative to rock salt is calcium magnesium acetate (CMA). Salt breaks down the surfaces of metals, concrete and asphalt, causing cracking and weakness with extended use season after season, where CMA is only as corrosive as ordinary tap water. Also, CMA is not harmful to vegetation where salt can be deadly to shrubs, orchards, gardens, and trees. CMA actually strengthens the soil and can stimulate plant growth by providing abundant organic acid in the way that liming a garden improves vitality. In surface water such as streams, lakes, and ponds, CMA does not stimulate algae growth or kill aquatic plants as salt does. For CMA to be as damaging to aquatic life as salt is, there would have to be three times the accumulation as that of salt to achieve even half of the damage. The downside to CMA is that it generally takes longer to melt ice and snow compared to rock salt, so it may not be as suitable for rapid ice removal.

Of course, there is the old chemical free option of shoveling. If you want to minimize the amount of work, just shovel a small walking path on sidewalks and two tire paths on driveways. Shoveling these pathways clear even part of the time while also using CMA reduces the chance of accidents and also lowers the threat of salt and chemical damage to the environment.